The Forest Service is proposing to use helicopters to ignite fire on 13,500 acres in the Mission Mountains Wilderness in northwest Montana. The agency also wants to plant white bark pine on 2,000 acres in the Wilderness. This burn and plant plan is part of a larger 15-year proposal which also includes logging up to 40,000 acres on the Flathead National Forest, between the Swan Mountains Crest and the northern portion of the Mission Mountains Wilderness. The agency’s actions would significantly manipulate this Wilderness and destroy the area’s wild character.
The Forest Service claims burning and logging is needed to reduce wildfire risk to homes, in particular hotter fires driven by climate change. However, this tired argument fails to address climate change as the underlying cause of hotter fires, or protect property or lives since scientific studies show home ignition is determined by condition of the home’s immediate area, not by conditions in forests far from communities.
The proposal is a slap in the face to Wilderness.
Helicopters are antithetical to Wilderness and prohibited by the Wilderness Act except in rare cases where such use is essential to wilderness protection or search and rescue operations. Helicopter use harasses wildlife and destroys the experience for wilderness visitors. Prescribed fire is in no way essential to protecting the Mission Mountains Wilderness, yet this proposal would allow an undetermined number of fire ignitions via helicopter in the Wilderness over a number of years. Further, there is nothing to prevent the Forest Service from instead allowing natural fires to burn in the Wilderness.
The Forest Service also wants to plant blister rust-resistant white bark pines in the Mission Mountains Wilderness. But, planting in Wilderness, regardless of how well intended, violates a fundamental tenet of Wilderness—that it remains “untrammeled by man,” or unmanipulated. Wilderness is a self-willed landscape, a place where we let nature roll the dice and let natural processes determine the conditions. Howard Zahniser, the author of the Wilderness Act, put it best when he implored us to be “guardians not gardeners.”
Not only will planting super trees manipulate the Wilderness, but it likely won’t work. Fungi like rust are highly adaptive and planting trees resistant (versus immune) to blister rust will likely select for rust that can overcome trees that were thought to be previously rust resistant. Trying to short-circuit an evolutionary process of adaption won’t likely work and may actually further endanger white bark pine across the landscape.
The Forest Service needs to let the Wilderness be wild, as the Wilderness Act requires.
Photo: Troy Smith via Flickr
Wilderness Watch is supporting a National Park Service (NPS) decision to remove the dilapidated Enchanted Valley Chalet in the Olympic Wilderness in Washington. The structure stands in the path of the East Fork Quinault River, and its eventual demise threatens to flood the wild river with brick, metal, wood, and other debris. The Park Service should allow natural conditions to be restored to the Wilderness.
On August 26, 2020, Wilderness Watch, together with a coalition of conservation organizations, filed a lawsuit to stop the Trump administration from reinstating cruel “hunting” practices on 19 million acres of America’s National Preserves in Alaska, which includes millions of acres of Wilderness. National Preserves in Alaska are administered by the National Park Service and are essentially national parks, except that they allow hunting. We are represented by Trustees for Alaska.
On August 24, 2020, the Gwitch’in Nation, together with a coalition of conservation organizations including Wilderness Watch, filed a lawsuit to stop the Administration’s decision to lease the coastal plain of the Arctic Refuge to oil and gas companies, and to turn America’s wildest landscape into another industrial wasteland. We are represented by Trustees for Alaska.Read more...
The Trump administration is proposing new regulations to open the Kenai National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska to brown bear baiting, to eliminate federal restrictions on trapping, and to expand snowmobiling, mountain biking, and ATV use in a significant part of the Refuge.
Wilderness Watch is opposing Bureau of Land Management (BLM), National Park Service (NPS), and Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) rulemaking to open up our federal public lands to electric bikes, or e-bikes. This means that all trails open to bikes will now be open to motorized bikes, and although individual managers can close individual trails to e-bike use, most will be loathe to do so. These rulemaking efforts are being made to implement Secretary of Interior David Bernhardt’s Secretarial Order…Read more...
The Okefenokee Wilderness, part of one of the world’s largest still intact blackwater swamp ecosystems and important habitat for native wildlife such as black bears, American alligators, and red-cockaded woodpeckers, is once again threatened by a titanium and zirconium mine at the doorstep of its namesake national wildlife refuge (NWR). The 354,000-acre Okefenokee Wilderness in southern Georgia makes up almost 90 percent of the Okefenokee NWR and is one of the largest Wilderness areas in the…Read more...
The Trump administration is at it again, this time taking a wrecking ball to America’s bedrock environmental law, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). NEPA is the only law that requires the federal government to consider the environmental impacts of its decisions and gives the public a voice in those decisions.