Mission Mountain Wilderness MontanaThe Forest Service is proposing to use helicopters to ignite fire on 13,500 acres in the Mission Mountains Wilderness in northwest Montana. The agency also wants to plant white bark pine on 2,000 acres in the Wilderness. This burn and plant plan is part of a larger 15-year proposal which also includes logging up to 40,000 acres on the Flathead National Forest, between the Swan Mountains Crest and the northern portion of the Mission Mountains Wilderness. The agency’s actions would significantly manipulate this Wilderness and destroy the area’s wild character.

  

The Forest Service claims burning and logging is needed to reduce wildfire risk to homes, in particular hotter fires driven by climate change. However, this tired argument fails to address climate change as the underlying cause of hotter fires, or protect property or lives since scientific studies show home ignition is determined by condition of the home’s immediate area, not by conditions in forests far from communities.

 

The proposal is a slap in the face to Wilderness.

 

Helicopters are antithetical to Wilderness and prohibited by the Wilderness Act except in rare cases where such use is essential to wilderness protection or search and rescue operations.  Helicopter use harasses wildlife and destroys the experience for wilderness visitors. Prescribed fire is in no way essential to protecting the Mission Mountains Wilderness, yet this proposal would allow an undetermined number of fire ignitions via helicopter in the Wilderness over a number of years. Further, there is nothing to prevent the Forest Service from instead allowing natural fires to burn in the Wilderness.

 

The Forest Service also wants to plant blister rust-resistant white bark pines in the Mission Mountains Wilderness. But, planting in Wilderness, regardless of how well intended, violates a fundamental tenet of Wilderness—that it remains “untrammeled by man,” or unmanipulated. Wilderness is a self-willed landscape, a place where we let nature roll the dice and let natural processes determine the conditions. Howard Zahniser, the author of the Wilderness Act, put it best when he implored us to be “guardians not gardeners.”

 

Not only will planting super trees manipulate the Wilderness, but it likely won’t work. Fungi like rust are highly adaptive and planting trees resistant (versus immune) to blister rust will likely select for rust that can overcome trees that were thought to be previously rust resistant. Trying to short-circuit an evolutionary process of adaption won’t likely work and may actually further endanger white bark pine across the landscape.

 

The Forest Service needs to let the Wilderness be wild, as the Wilderness Act requires.

 

 

Photo: Troy Smith via Flickr

 
 
 
 
Buffalo Plateau
April 21, 2021

Poison has no place in the Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness

The Forest Service (FS) needs to reject a proposal by the Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Parks (FWP) to poison 43 miles of Buffalo Creek plus two lakes in the Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness in Montana, which is part of the famed Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. 
Read more...
Cattle trespassing near Pecos Wilderness, New Mexico, by George Wuerthner
April 17, 2021

Drop Trump-era Forest Service grazing plan

Wilderness Watch is urging the Forest Service to drop its proposed changes to its livestock grazing program on millions of acres of public lands, including Wilderness. The FS’s Rangeland Management Directives were released in the waning days of the Trump administration, and have huge implications for wildlife and Wilderness. 
Read more...
Crooked Creek in the Wenaha-Tucannon Wilderness
April 09, 2021

Treat the Wenaha-Tucannon like the Wilderness it is

Wilderness Watch is urging the Forest Service (FS) to adopt a wilderness-compatible alternative for addressing the burned out bridge at Crooked Creek in the Wenaha-Tucannon Wilderness in Oregon. The agency is proposing to build a new a bridge at the site of a former 80-foot entirely wooden bridge destroyed by fire in 2015.
Read more...
Red Cliffs NRA BLM
March 30, 2021

Litigation on National Park Service e-bike rule will proceed

On Tuesday, March 30, we received good news about our lawsuit to restore the ban on electric-powered bikes, or e-bikes, on non-motorized trails in National Parks. A federal judge rejected the former Trump Administration’s November 2020 motion to dismiss, calling a key portion of the administration’s argument “nonsensical.” The ruling gives our case the go-ahead to proceed.

Read more...
North Fork Blackfoot River Scapegoat Wilderness Montana
March 03, 2021

Montana Proposing to Poison the Famed Scapegoat Wilderness

Wilderness Watch is urging the Forest Service to reject a Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Parks (FWP) plan to poison 67 miles of the North Fork Blackfoot River and its headwater tributaries and three small lakes in the Scapegoat Wilderness, in an attempt to kill the non-native fish the FWP has been stocking in these streams for decades.
Read more...
Whitebark Pines in the Mission Mountains Wilderness
February 01, 2021

Protect Wilderness in Whitebark Pine Listing

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) is considering listing whitebark pine under the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA). The listing rule must make clear that interventions and manipulations (e.g. agency-ignited fire, genetic selection and seedling planting, and chemical applications) are not appropriate in designated Wilderness as protected under the 1964 Wilderness Act. Instead, natural processes and natural selection must be protected and valued in the broader effort to protect…
Read more...
aichilik 200x150
January 22, 2021

President Biden Delivers on Promise to Arctic Refuge

The Arctic Refuge gained a reprieve on 1/20/20 when President Biden issued an executive order placing a temporary moratorium on federal government activities aimed at implementing the Trump Administration’s oil and gas leasing program on the Coastal Plain. Biden’s order, citing inadequate environmental review and related legal questions, directs the Secretary to review the leasing program and conduct a new environmental analysis.

Read more...

Victory: Air Force drops Gila overflights plan!

Learn more...

Alpine Lakes Wilderness Threatened by Thirsty Chelan County

Learn more...

Destructive Grazing Threatens Gila and Blue Range Wildernesses

Learn more...

Herbicides and Burning Six Wildernesses in Arizona

Learn more...

Massive Burn Proposed for the Mission Mountains Wilderness

Learn more...

We're Suing to Stop Cruel Hunting Practices on National Preserves in Alaska

Learn more...

Good News for Brown Bears in the Kenai Refuge

Learn more...

Don't Trammel the Palisades Wilderness Study Area

Learn more...

WW Sues to End the Killing of Grizzly Bears at Bait Stations

Learn more...

Izembek Road Quashed Again

Learn more...

WW Objects to Wilderness Helicopter Invasion in Arizona

Learn more...

Helicopter Net-Gun Capture Stopped in Wasatch Wildernesses

Learn more...

Allow Natural Recovery of Grizzlies in the North Cascades

Learn more...

Degrading the Wave at Paria Canyon-Vermillion Cliffs

Learn more...

Ambler Road Threatens Gates of the Arctic Wilderness

Learn more...

WW Stops Wilderness “Chainsaw Massacre” in Colorado

Learn more...

Keep Grazing Allotments Closed in Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness

Learn more...

E-Bike rules threaten public lands, wildlife, and Wilderness

Learn more...

Massive Strip Mine Threatens One of the East's largest Wildernesses

Learn more...

National Environmental Policy Act on the line

Learn more...

Keep the Promise of a Wild Cumberland Island

Learn more...

BLM's "Loony" Action


Learn more...

Time to Close Airstrips in River of No Return Wilderness

Learn more...

Seismic Exploration Threatens Arctic Refuge

Learn more...

WW appeals livestock grazing permit renewals in Colorado

Learn more...

Leave the Cascades and Olympic Wildernesses Be

Learn more...

Keep Cows out of the Hoover Wilderness

Learn more...

No Permanent Firebreaks in the Ventana Wilderness

Learn more...

Wilderness Community Unites to Keep Bike Ban in Wilderness

Learn more...

Proposed BLM grazing regs threaten Wilderness across the West

Learn more...

Wilderness and Mining Don't Mix

Learn more...

WW Sues to Stop Motorboat Abuse in Boundary Waters


Learn more...

Restore Wilderness in Olympic National Park

Learn more...

Sulfide Mines Threaten Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness

Learn more...

BLM Seeking to Commercialize Wildernesses in New Mexico

Learn more...

WW Challenges Increased Grazing in Little Jacks Creek Wilderness

Learn more...

Commercial Spaceport Threatens Cumberland Island Wilderness

Learn more...

Remove Pemigewasset Wilderness Bridge

Learn more...

Wilderness Watch Opposes Human Meddling in Boundary Waters

Learn more...

Let the Pine Valley Mountain Wilderness Be

Learn more...

Visitor Permit System Coming to Central Cascades Wildernesses

Learn more...

Commercial Use Threatens Pasayten and Lake Chelan-Sawtooth Wildernesses

Learn more...

Victory for River of No Return Wilderness and its Wildlife

Learn more...

BLM Drops Owyhee Canyonlands Wilderness Juniper Project

Learn more...

Kootznoowoo Wilderness Spared an Airport

Learn more...

WW Urges a Wilder Yosemite and Mt. Rainer Wilderness

Learn more...

Park Service Should Protect Nation’s Largest Wilderness

Learn more...

When the Cure is Worse than the Disease

Learn more...

Victory for six Owyhee Wildernesses in Idaho!

Learn more...

It’s Time to Remove Domestic Sheep in the High Uintas Wilderness

Learn more...

Congress Allows Unethical Killing in Wildlife Refuges in Alaska

Learn more...

Military Drops Plans to Land Helicopters in the Alpine Lakes Wilderness

Learn more...

Another Building Boom in the Olympics

Learn more...

Forest Service Proposes Logging and Burning Wildernesses in Arizona

Learn more...

Supersonic jet flights threaten Owyhee Wildernesses and wildlife

Learn more...

Wilderness Watch Votes for Nature's Way

Learn more...

Contact Us

Wilderness Watch
P.O. Box 9175
Missoula, MT 59807
P: 406-542-2048
E: wild@wildernesswatch.org

Minneapolis, MN Office
2833 43rd Avenue South
Minneapolis, MN 55406

P: 612-201-9266

Moscow, ID Office
P.O. Box 9765
Moscow, ID 83843

Stay Connected

flogo RGB HEX 512   Twitter Logo gold   Insta gold

Search

Go to top